Manblunder Comments

COMMENTS

Chakravarti
March 31, 2026 08:03 AM

The issue of taking a book itself as one's guru is a contentious one, for it is in direct opposition to the most fundamental rule of mantra sastra as elucidated in countless tantras - do not take mantras from books but received them from guru mukha. Taking mantras from books and practising them in the view of the Tantras is a most heinous sin and a direct offence against Siva himself. You yourself have advocated this line several times in your guidance to sadhakas on this site. As such, it is extremely disruptive to the traditional position, that is vehemently against book-dependence, to note the "lateral" position that one may take a scripture or a book (and not necessarily God) as one's guru (under certain circumstances). Hence my request for additional information and references. If it can be shown that the tantras themselves, and not just one tantra , anticipated the problems with finding proper gurus that we face today, we can confidently state that such fail safe mechanisms are also traditional, and not some fabrication. I trust you appreciate my position on this issue. Thanks.

RASIT
March 31, 2026 06:03 AM

Kashik, like to thank you for your recommendation. I hadn't heard before about Guru Gita, and now ordered one. Thanks again!

Wildfire
March 30, 2026 11:03 PM

Did u get sri harsha ramamurthy sirs contact information? If yes, then pls share it with me.

Kashik
March 30, 2026 09:03 PM

There are 3 kavachs - first invokes the Guru mandala blessing. 2nd kavach is to invoke blessings of current guru, replace "amukh guru" with the deeksha nama of your guru like "amritananda natha saraswati prasada siddhidatriye jape viniyoga". 3rd kavach to is to open gyan marg.

Kashik
March 30, 2026 09:03 PM

Hello i request you download the pdf as i will be closing the link since it explicitly mentioned not to publicize/write it down. I only share this with you due to seeing you always mention your guru and devotion towards guru. One more advice i want to give if you already not doing it is to add scripture called guru gita. It has 3 chapter take around 35-45 min to read all the chapters at Once. You could read atleast 1 chapter daily as it explicitly mention that just by reading the guru gita it give the same fruit one receives when present near guru.

Amargi
March 30, 2026 07:03 PM

thank you Kashik, may you also be guided with love.

Kashik
March 30, 2026 05:03 PM

Hello amargi do you also chant guru kavach inorder to get blessings and success in sadhana through guru mandala shakti heres the link : https://drive.google.com/file/d/1vz8_sP49syoa4m0B2YSvql1-vUrVva_p/view?usp=drivesdk

Ram
March 30, 2026 04:03 PM

Namaskarm Guruji In Sri Swarnakarshana Bhairava Mantra Japa you have given 56 letters mantra and in Sri Swarnakarshana Bhairava Stotram you have given 58 letters mantra which includes aim hrim shrim aim shrim and which one is the the correct mantra given in script by Brahma rishi 56 letters or 58 letters mantra ? Thank you

Sheetal
March 30, 2026 01:03 PM

Sri Matre Namah. why is ॐ ऐं ह्रीं श्रीं added at the beginning of the panch dashakshri mantra? if there is already article explaining it, can you please direct me to the same? thank you,

Vipul
March 30, 2026 09:03 AM

Jay maa. Prince can you please explain why is it said that worship of Guhyakali leads to worship of Kamkala kali or that worship of Kamkala kali can't be done without first obtaining grace of Guhyakali? That is if what I stated is correct. It is often said that in a way, Guhyakali is the source of Kamakala kali right? That's what I understood from multiple comments of the wise people like tripuraghna, tivra, and Jothi ji.

CATEGORIES

ARTICLES