Manblunder Comments

COMMENTS

Stormbreaker
November 04, 2026 01:11 PM

Namaste Sriram ji, is there a Agamic Sandhyavandam in Shrividya for non-Dvijas? Also can Lalitha Sahasranamam (just the names, no nyasa or any rituals) be recited without deeksha? what does the shashtras say about it? Thank you.

Kashik
November 04, 2026 11:11 AM

Namaste everyone, does anyone know who is Cañcalo Jyotir Nirañjanaḥ Prabhuḥ(चञ्चलो ज्योतिर्निरञ्जनः प्रभुः) ?

Sriram
November 03, 2026 11:11 AM

Dear chaitanya. No, Gayatri should not be replaced with panchadashi. In the phalasruti of Lalitha Sahasranama, lord Hayagriva explicitly states - "prātaḥ snātvā vidhānena sandhyā karma samāpya ca | pūjā gṛhaṃ tato gatvā cakra rājaṃ samarcayet || vidyāṃ japet sahasraṃ vā triśataṃ śatam eva vā | rahasya nāma sāhasram idaṃ paścāt paṭhen naraḥ ||". It means "after the morning bath, do the SANDHYA KARMA (sandhya vandanam). THEN go to the pooja room, do archanam of sri chakra. Then do the japa of panchadasi 1000 times, 300 times or atleast 100 times. Then read the Lalitha Sahasranama". So lord hayagriva himself instructs to do panchadasi japa only after doing the sandhyavandana. Also, the devi bhagavata purana states that Dvija is a tree. Gayatri is his root. Vedam is his trunk. ALL OTHER ACTIVITIES ARE ONLY THE BRANCHES, LEAVES AND FRUITS. It also states - "chinne mūle na vṛkṣo naiva śākhāḥ | tasmāt nityaṃ prakartavyaṃ sandhyopāsanam uttamam || (When the root is cut off, there is neither the tree nor its branches. So the excellent sandhyavandanam(gayatri) should be done daily)."

Sriram
November 03, 2026 11:11 AM

The devi bhagavata purana statement is applicable only for the ones initiated into the gayatri, as these rules are stated in the last 2 sections of the purana, which speaks only about gayatri. For the ones not initiated into Gayatri, the tantric sandhyavandan given by the Guru is the root, which should be performed before any other activities. The same statement is applicable when Lord hayagriva says "do sandhya karma before panchadasi"

Kashik
November 02, 2026 10:11 PM

Namaste tvaritha thank you for such wonderful explanation, I want to ask what are the names of night Sandhya 12:00-3:00am, if I am correct there are three more Sandhyas after nishita kaal sandhya with their own names, and what is the time of kalratri is it midnight 12:00am? Thank you.

Tvaritha
November 02, 2026 09:11 PM

Namaste Stormbreaker Unfortunately, I am not dīkṣit into Śaiva Tantra. Rules about pradakṣiṇa, and other concepts explained in the Kṣetracaitanyarahasyam are not sect-specific, and are concerned with explaining the tātparya of common ritual acts and their scriptural basis, so I have quoted it. I do not know much about Śaiva Tantra.

Tvaritha
November 02, 2026 09:11 PM

Hi Chaitanya, I am not sure, but traditionally, when a dvija is initiated into an Āgamik Sandhya, he performs it separately after Vaidiki Sandhya without mixing, or missing either.

chaitanya
November 02, 2026 08:11 PM

Namaskaram , can one replace Gayatri mantra japa with Panchadasi mantra in sandhya vandanam if one is initiated ?

Stormbreaker
November 02, 2026 07:11 PM

Namaste Ji, I had few questions and wanted to ask you personally on Shaiva Tantram, especially since you have read Madavji's books. Is it possible to contact you through mail? I can share my contact mail Id too if you do not want to be disturbed with many mails, mine is qftheory1920@gmail.com

Stormbreaker
November 02, 2026 07:11 PM

Dear Tvaritha Ji, the message was intended for you, if it became confusing.

CATEGORIES

ARTICLES